
A MacIver News Service Investigation
By Bill Osmulski
MacIver News Service | January 26, 2011
[Madison, Wisc…] The swearing in of Governor Scott Walker earlier this month failed to eliminate former Governor Jim Doyle’s influence on public policy in Wisconsin, as many of Doyle’s key policy personnel have now burrowed deep into the state bureaucracy.
In November, Walker sent a letter to Governor Doyle hoping to forestall such events.
“In the past, it has been common practice for political appointees to use this time to ‘bump down’ into permanent civil service positions,” Walker wrote in November. “I believe these appointees should be required to go through the same application process as any other civil servants and my Administration will review any new permanent hires during the next two months so they can be considered for termination during the probationary period.”
Not all the individuals closely associated with Doyle’s administration landed in obscure corners of state government. Some of them were able to secure relatively high-ranking positions within Walker’s Administration. So while Walker moves to enact his policies, there are individuals within state agencies that were working to implement a vastly different agenda only weeks ago.
Chris Patton, who served as Doyle’s Senior Policy Director and who oversaw the dispersal of federal stimulus funds as the Director of the Office of Recovery and Reinvestment, is now the Policy Initiative Advisor in the Department of Administration. His annual salary (based on the standard 40 hour work week) totals more than $95,000, not including benefits.

Randall Romanski was Doyle’s Secretary of the Department of Agriculture, Trade, and Consumer Protection for the final few months of Administration. He had once served as Doyle’s deputy chief of staff. Romanski is now the Program and Policy Chief at the Department of Transportation.
Ruben Anthony Jr. served as Doyle’s Wisconsin Department of Transportation Deputy Secretary and is now a manager in that department.
Anthony fell into controversy back in 2005 when he invited dozens of individuals to a Doyle re-election fundraiser, who were associated with engineering firms bidding on $100 million in state contracts. Press reports at the time indicated Anthony had the final say in which firm would get the contracts. The Wisconsin Ethics Board determined there was no evidence Anthony tried to coerce the firms into attending the fundraiser and no state laws were violated.
The name of the new Public Health Manager at the Department of Health Services might also be familiar. Oskar Anderson worked at the Department of Revenue in 2007 where, according to press accounts, he personally oversaw the controversial sales-tax tracking system project, which cost the state $28.2 million, before it was scrapped altogether. Anderson then became the Chief Information Officer at DOA.
According to the Wisconsin Office of State Employment Relations, career executive positions are filled with highly qualified candidates having excellent administrative skills.
Linda Barth, Doyle’s Executive Assistant for the Department of Revenue is now the Employment Relations Program Coordinator in the Department of Administration.
These moves not only perpetuate Doyle’s legacy in Wisconsin government, they also carry a significant cost. There were more than a hundred personnel changes after the election. Of the many position shifts after the election, 84 were career executive positions. The total annual cost for those salaries is $7 million alone, and the average salary based on a 40-hour work week is $83,250. Those figures do not include benefits.
Doyle’s former Assistant to the Legislative Director, Matthew Sweeney, secured the largest raise in these last minute personnel changes. He moved to the Department of Revenue as the legislative liaison on December 12th with a $14.84 per hour increase or a $30,900 a year raise, based on the standard 40-hour work week.
Not every individual listed received a salary increase. In fact Rachel Currans-Sheehan, now the Section Chief for Pharmacy and Quality, Wisconsin Medicaid within the Department of Health Services, took a pay cut of $18.58 per hour in base salary. Previously, she had served as the DHS Executive Assistant and before that as legislative liaison for the department.
Earlier this month, MNS reported on several individuals who found soft landings at the Public Service Commission, the state body that regulates utilities.
To secure this information for this report, the MacIver News Service filed a Freedom of Information Act request with the Office of State Employee Relations for a list of all career executive appointments since October 1, 2010 and a list of all Doyle appointees that had been returned to civil service in that same timeframe.
The MacIver News Service received a spreadsheet listing 100 names of individuals who had received career executive appointments since October their current salary, their previous position, and their previous pay. MNS also requested and received a second spreadsheet containing 31 names of appointees who had been restored to civil service jobs, their old jobs and salary information, and their new jobs and salary information.
Regarding the career executive positions, MacIver News Service also asked Wisconsin Office of State Employment Relations for a “Listing of who previously held those positions, when they became vacant, and the previous salaries.” To date OSER has not responded to that request.
According to the OSER website, the broad opportunities for career advancement and mobility are provided to career executive incumbents. Agencies are able to fill career executive positions efficiently and quickly.
From the website:
A vacancy in a career executive position may be filled through an open competitive examination, a competitive promotional examination or by restricting competition to employees in career executive positions in order to achieve and maintain a highly competent work force in career executive positions, with due consideration for affirmative action.
When a career executive vacancy for which the person is qualified and eligible occurs, the person may be reinstated at the discretion of the appointing authority within a five-year period from the date of separation. The appointing authority has the discretion to require a person, who is eligible for reinstatement to a career executive position, to participate in the competitive examination process.
